Aug 19, 2019

Invoking ‘State Secrets’: Still the Status Quo?

Published Feb 24, 2011, 9:50pm
Invoking ‘State Secrets’: Still the Status Quo?

News brought to you by:
InfoKwik Web Design, Marketing & Hosting Kansas City

Invoking 'State Secrets': Still Status Quo?

by Marian Wang ProPublica, Feb. 24, 2011, 12:09 p.m.February 23, 2011

Earlier this week, we flagged [1] an interesting piece in the New York Times about the U.S. government invoking the state secrets privilege to block evidence in lawsuits against a contractor who had duped the U.S. government into spending millions on what many now consider to be fake counterterrorism technology [2].

According to another recent report, the U.S. invoked state secrets to block a personal injury lawsuit [3] by a CIA employee who alleged that environmental contamination in his home made his family sick. That got us wondering about what else the U.S. has invoked state secrets for—particularly under the Obama administration, which had pledged to end abuses of the privilege [4].

"Numbers aside, there is a great deal of continuity between the Bush and Obama administrations,” Steven Aftergood, a government secrecy expert with the Federation of American Scientists, told us. “And there is no case where the Obama administration has rescinded a claim of state secrets privilege that was advanced by the Bush [administration]."

Here’s a quick review of some of them:

To block a lawsuit seeking to prevent the U.S. government from killing Anwar Al-Awlaki, an American citizen accused of having ties to al-Qaeda. The Times noted that while the U.S. government did not confirm [5] that Awlaki was on its “targeted killings” list, it invoked the state secrets privilege, arguing that [6] the case “cannot be litigated without risking or requiring the disclosure of classified and privileged intelligence information that must not be disclosed.”

To block evidence in lawsuits against government contractors involved in the government’s extraordinary rendition program. Months after President Obama took office, his Justice Department surprised federal judges [7] by invoking the state secrets privilege again in a case filed by five detainees who said they were abducted and flown to other countries—where they allege they were tortured—on flights arranged by a Boeing subsidiary.

To block lawsuits over the Bush administration’s domestic wiretapping program. In one case inherited from the Bush administration, Obama’s Justice Department continued to argue that classified records of eavesdropping on an Islamic charity were state secrets [8]. That evidence was excluded, and the case was allowed to proceed. Wired magazine noted that the two wiretapped lawyers were awarded $20,400 each, a ruling that last week the Obama administration indicated it would appeal [9].

In another case [10], Attorney General Eric Holder said the department “specifically looked for a way to allow this case to proceed while carving out classified information, and ultimately concluded there was no way to do so.” As a candidate, Barack Obama had previously called the surveillance program “unconstitutional and illegal [11].”

Online News Association Professional Member
InfoKwik KC News is a Professional Member

Custom KC News Search

    Advertise on this site

    AddThis Feed Button


    To instant news updates in your email.

    Never miss a story!

    Tags: state secrets privilege abuse

    Add a Comment

    Please be civil.

    (Use Markdown for formatting.)

    This question helps prevent spam:

    Browse more...



    Find a Job
    Job category:

    Search This Site
    Search this site or any KC Web Guide

    Got Feedback?
    Send a letter to the editor.

    Sign up for the Free E-Newsletter.
    Also receive updates automatically in your email.

    Promote your brand at

    When Insults Had Class...

    "He has all the virtues I dislike and none of the vices I admire."

    - Winston Churchill

    "A modest little person, with much to be modest about."

    - Winston Churchill

    "I have never killed a man, but I have read many obituaries with great pleasure."

    - Clarence Darrow

    "He has never been known to use a word that might send a reader to the dictionary."

    - William Faulkner (about Ernest Hemingway)

    "Poor Faulkner. Does he really think big emotions come from big words?"

    - Ernest Hemingway (about William Faulkner)

    "Thank you for sending me a copy of your book; I'll waste no time reading it."

    - Moses Hadas

    "He can compress the most words into the smallest idea of any man I know."

    - Abraham Lincoln

    "I've had a perfectly wonderful evening. But this wasn't it."

    - Groucho Marx

    "I didn't attend the funeral, but I sent a nice letter saying I approved of it."

    - Mark Twain

    "He has no enemies, but is intensely disliked by his friends."

    - Oscar Wilde

    "I am enclosing two tickets to the first night of my new play; bring a friend... if you have one."

    - George Bernard Shaw to Winston Churchill

    "Cannot possibly attend first night, will attend second... if there is one."

    - Winston Churchill, in reply

    More Quotes